Energy Efficient Conversion

Commercial buildings and Section J

NCC 2022, Volume 1

Area of NCC Requirements:

• J1.3 Roof and ceiling construction
• J1.5 Roof lights
• J1.6 Roof lights – additional requirements
• J1.7 Roof and ceiling construction – additional requirements
• J1.9 Sealing of openings

The Challenge

Data centres are not typical commercial buildings. They rely on extensive mechanical services, plant equipment, and maintenance infrastructure—often concentrated on the roof. In this project, the roof design incorporated numerous penetrations and mounted elements such as platforms, condensers, walkways, and fall protection systems.

The problem is that highly serviced roofs interrupt the continuity of insulation and air sealing. That makes strict compliance with the Deemed-to-Satisfy (DTS) provisions under Section J difficult or impractical to achieve, particularly for roof construction and sealing requirements. Without an alternative compliance pathway, the project risked failing to demonstrate compliance with NCC energy efficiency requirements.

What This Really Means

Section J is outcome-driven: it is intended to ensure that the building as a whole achieves suitable energy efficiency, not that every individual element matches a prescriptive detail in isolation.

Where roof geometry and services create unavoidable discontinuities, the relevant question becomes whether the overall building performance still meets the NCC’s required energy efficiency standard. That is where performance pathways become essential—especially for buildings like data centres where operational loads and servicing needs fundamentally change the design constraints.

The Solution

A performance-based assessment was undertaken using a whole-building verification approach consistent with the NCC framework.

The assessment considered:

• How roof penetrations and mounted services affect insulation continuity and sealing outcomes
• Whether the building envelope, as a system, achieves acceptable thermal and air leakage performance
• How other building elements and services can contribute to overall energy performance outcomes
• Whether the proposed design performs at least as well as a DTS-compliant reference building
• How assumptions and inputs are documented to ensure a transparent and reviewable approval pathway

Rather than forcing the roof to comply prescriptively despite practical constraints, the performance pathway focused on proving that the building’s total energy performance meets or exceeds NCC intent.

Why This Matters

The final assessment confirmed that the proposed design achieved energy performance outcomes equivalent to, or better than, a compliant reference building, satisfying the intent of JP1. By using a documented performance-based pathway, the project maintained approval certainty while accommodating the realities of a highly serviced, mission-critical roof design.

This is a strong example of how performance solutions enable complex buildings to meet NCC requirements without compromising essential operational infrastructure.

DTS restricting your design creativity? 

Reach out to our team for the solution.